Monday, April 6, 2009

Assessment tips

For the next lesson, you will be sitting through a timed assessment where you will be asked to write a commentary based on one of the three articles Mr Kelvin Yap had posted onto Ask n Learn, or one of your own (your choice). You are therefore advised to read them all before bringing them into the class, and be prepared to attempt a commentary on at least one of them.

A commentary should convey your opinion, so don't be afraid to use the personal voice - "I feel that...", "I think that..." are all valid statements to use.

Note the rubric used for the assessment - predicting a counter-argument (for your opinion) and rebutting it is expected. For a good score, the following structure is suggested for your essay.
Introductory Paragraph
-Motivator
-Thesis Statement
-Blueprint

Body Paragraph #1 (Argument)
-Topic Sentence
-Specific Support
      -Evidence
      -Explanation of Evidence

Body Paragraph #2 (Rebuttal)
-State possible counter-argument to your thesis statement)
-Explain this counter-argument
-Topic Sentence (refute the counter-argument)
-Specific Support
      -Evidence
      -Explanation of Evidence

Concluding Paragraph
-Reworded Thesis Statement
-Clincher

3 comments:

  1. are we allowed to use a topic other than that given?? Because my other friends who are taught by My. Yap are all using topics other than those given. They say, we must just provide the source material....(even AskNlEarn says so)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yes, as per the Ask n Learn instructions - you may choose another topic/source material if you desire. However, none of the three topics covered earlier (streaking, embryonic stem cell research, orchard road facelift) should be repeated.

    (Blog post updated to clarify instructions)

    ReplyDelete
  3. @Rohan: "other friends who are taught by My. Yap"

    Sia la.

    ReplyDelete